IIMA study reveals major post-IBC recovery; Sales up 89%
A comprehensive study released by the Indian Institute of Management Ahmedabad (IIMA), in collaboration with the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (IBBI), highlights a transformative era for distressed firms in India. The research reveals that average sales for resolved firms witnessed a significant surge of 89% in the five years following resolution.
Key Findings of the Study
While net margins remain under pressure, these firms have successfully reached operational breakeven, with average operating margins climbing to 8% by the fifth year post-resolution—a stark reversal from the -26% recorded during the year of bankruptcy. Furthermore, a 106% increase in average capital expenditure (CAPEX) indicates a strong recovery in asset growth and robust management confidence in future economic health.
Key Financial Turnarounds
The study adopts an “event-year window” approach to track firm performance up to five years post-resolution (t+5). The empirical data shows a broad-based recovery across several critical metrics:
- Market Valuation: For listed entities, the aggregate market capitalization skyrocketed from INR 2.8 lakh crore to approximately INR 9 lakh crore, reflecting a massive three-fold increase in investor confidence.
- Profitability Convergence: Multiple measures, including EBITDA-to-assets and Return on Capital Employed (ROCE), exhibit statistically significant improvements, signaling that post-resolution growth is value-enhancing rather than just scale-driven.
- Asset Growth: Average assets grew from INR 228.33 crores in the resolution year to INR 254.60 crores by the fifth year, representing an 11.5% gain.
Liquidity and Operational Efficiency
The “liquidity crunch” that typically leads to insolvency has been largely mitigated through the restructuring process. The following metrics illustrate this improvement:
| Metric | Year of Bankruptcy | 5 Years Post-Resolution | Improvement (%) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Current Ratio (CA/CL) | 1.0 | 2.09 | ~106% |
| Asset Turnover | 0.37 | 0.87 | ~131% |
The IIMA report also finds significant improvements in Activity Ratios, such as inventory and receivables turnover, suggesting that new management teams are more effective at managing material purchases and collection efforts.
Employment and Social Impact
Contrary to the narrative of job losses during bankruptcy, the study finds that resolved firms are actively increasing their labor force:
- Employee Expenses: There was a 71.91% increase in average employee expenses in the five years post-resolution, indicating higher employment intensity.
- Labor Strength: For listed firms, employee strength per unit of total assets rose by 200% from the year of resolution to t+5.
Recovery Rates by Industry
The average recovery rate for creditors stands at 37.5%, marking an improvement over 2023 benchmarks. Performance varies significantly across sectors:
| Industry | Highest Recovery Rates | Lowest Recovery Rates |
|---|---|---|
| Financial Creditors | 43% | Hotels and Restaurants; Health and Social Work |
| Operational Creditors | Hotels and Restaurants | Transport, Storage and Communications |
Financial creditors realized an average recovery of 43%, while operational creditors saw a return of 25%.
The Cost of Delay
The IIMA report warns that delays in the resolution process directly erode value. The researchers identified a non-linear relationship between resolution time and expenses. In the Wholesale and Retail Trade sector, for instance, high complexity led to an average expense ratio of 47% of the realizable amount, the highest among all industries studied.
Conclusion
The study concludes that resolved firms are no longer just surviving but are converging with the performance metrics of healthy peers, actively contributing to the overall economic activity of India.
Note: The findings of this study underscore the importance of timely interventions in the insolvency process to maximize recovery and enhance the economic viability of distressed firms.
